Sturgeon Bay hotellia

Plussat: The rooms were small, but clean and confortable.

Plussat: The history of the hotel and the 50'S theme. I felt right at home. We even made a campfire in the evening and met some interesting people.

Plussat: This is the most unique place I’ve ever stayed in Door County. The owners clearly love what they’ve created and the environment is adorable and so well curated.

Miinukset: The rooms are small, at least the one I stayed in was, which was fine as I was traveling solo.

Plussat: Everything very clean

Miinukset: Just noisy people at 7am in hall and diner areas

Plussat: Very clean, nice staff. Breakfast had a nice selection of food, cereal, fresh fruit, boiled eggs, muffins, pastries and toast. Loved the 50's furniture & atmosphere.

Miinukset: Bed was VERY firm. I like to take my breakfast to my room and a sign in the kitchen asked patrons not to do that.

Plussat: Great nostalgic hotel

Miinukset: realy nothing

Plussat: Liked the breakfast. Very informal. Nice choices. Lots of info about Door County events.

Plussat: The location was perfect.

Miinukset: For the price of the room, I anticipated a hot/made to order breakfast, like omelettes and potatoes.

Plussat: This motel has a wonderful concept...love that the stay there helped to fund local musicians! Otherwise, it is an absolutely fine motel with a nice breakfast. Very much loved the feel of the place, with the 1950's style flourishes.

Plussat: Lovely little motel. We enjoyed our stay here and the staff were very nice. The breakfast was a lovely bonus.

Miinukset: It's too pricey for what you get.

Plussat: Classic 50’s decor. Music theme throughout. Friendly staff.

Plussat: The retro atmosphere was a delightful surprise! Learning the history of the facility added to the charm. Others staying were friendly and interaction was easy in the breakfast area, again very reminesent of days gone by.

Miinukset: Nothing

Plussat: Location is perfect. Rooms are clean. Staff is very professional.

Plussat: Fantastic property. The suite was a perfect size for the 4 of us, gave us plenty of space to cook and relax and chill out. Our two girls loved the swimming pools, we spent over 1 1/2 hours a day playing in them. The whirlpool was a welcome treat for us adults.

Miinukset: Nothing - great property in a great location.

Plussat: Beautiful views, clean rooms,

Miinukset: Outside building needing washing

Miinukset: Window AC unit made it difficult to keep the bedroom cool.

Plussat: The staff was amazing, Luke, Brian and Annie-helpful, caring, We had an emergency in our family and had to leave on Friday evening so we lost a night there. The location is the best in Sturgeon Bay.

Miinukset: no negative feelings

Plussat: The view. The staff

Plussat: Great location, easy to get anywhere on the peninsula. Beautiful grounds and the rooms were very nice & exceptionally clean. Very peaceful and relaxing atmosphere.

Miinukset: Not sure what could be done about this but the water pressure in the showers was very low and both cell & wifi reception was very spotty

Plussat: Spectacular grounds! Best Bay view in Door County! Very nice unit, staff was polite and attentive. We booked at the last minute for our wedding anniversary and fell in love with the views and sounds of water lapping at the shore as we sat on the pier bench!

Miinukset: When we checked in we walked into bedroom to find the carpeting was sopping wet and musty smell. The gentleman at the desk was very attentive and concerned, the only solution was a small fan running all night on the floor to help dry the carpet. The blind header in bedroom was broken and fell off, and when you come into bedroom there is garbage again the wall behind tv unit, hard not to see it as it is a direct sight line when entering the room. The kitchen clock glass is cracked, when we told the front desk he said it probably was from a beer party. The baseboard trim in bathrooms is very old and painted slopped all over it and caulking. The showers have mold/mildew on bottom door runner and master shower stall has no light so it’s a dimly light shower in the morning. These are all things that could be taken care of quickly and not for a ton of money, so it was disappointing to pay this kind of money to have sloppy work, wet carpeting, and broken/unkept items such as this. I bet the unit owner will not be happy about how the maintenance team is handling their rental. Westwood Shores Management Team - you can do better! The view is advertised as water which is true of living room and it is awesome! The bedroom views lack the stunning water views as it is a corner unit, and the view is a small patio area and exterior walls.

Plussat: Perfect spot. Nice outdoor and indoor pool. Friendly staff. Every room has a view, some better than others.

Plussat: Property was excellent.

Plussat: Great suites, beautiful location, breathtaking views, great off season prices.

Miinukset: No

Plussat: We loved this hotel. All rooms have a view of the lake. The location was great, just north of town. We loved the indoor pool, hot tub, & sauna. The front deck crew was always very helpful when we had a question. Will come back again.

Miinukset: Not really everything was perfect.

Plussat: Loved the coziness of the room and the bed. Landscaping on the property was beautiful as well.

Plussat: We like everything. Very comfortable.

Miinukset: A refrigerator in the room.

Plussat: breakfast was excellent

Miinukset: Wifi was poor

Plussat: Very charming and welcoming.

Miinukset: Would rather have stayed farther north into door county, but this is our first visit.

Plussat: The set breakfast was great. The location was good with a selection of restaurants for dinner nearby. It was also a good starting point for exploring Door County. The property has a lovely garden.

Miinukset: The room lacked a bedside table (night stand) on one side of the bed which was a little tricky. Other than that the facilities were very good

Plussat: The beds were excellent. Breakfast was delicious!

Miinukset: Very small tv in room.

Plussat: The Breakfast was very good and the rooms where lovely

Plussat: Wonderful breakfast. Great location and pretty neighborhood.

Miinukset: Property a bit dated and common areas a bit cluttered. Expected a bit classier place for the price.

Plussat: Breakfast was good. Room was clean. Bed was comfortable. Breakfast server very nice. Loved the porch.

Miinukset: Room was very dark. Sink area very small, but probably can't be helped. Could use a towel ring there. We arrived early and stopped to let the innkeeper know that we had arrived and wanted to park there while we shopped. He was a bit irritated with us for being early and assumed that we wanted to check in. We weren't told some of the nice things to know, like cookies are available.

Plussat: The location is very nice. Right outside the inn one has access and a nice, quiet garden. We enjoyed the water access. The location was also convenient, as the inn is only 2-3 minutes from highway 42. Sturgeon bay has good breakfast restaurants nearby. The bathroom was in good condition with newer appliances. The kitchenette was equipped.

Miinukset: The room was much smaller than the rooms we saw on the site. We were surprised by the size of the room (room#7). The bed and pillows were rock hard and the first two nights we were quite uncomfortable. One of us has moderate asthma and when we walked into the room we were hit by a strong, chemical smell (something between a room freshener and a strong laundry detergent). We aired the room for about an hour, but I was having some difficulty breathing after smelling that. We finally figured out it was the bed and pillow cover and we put it in a drawer. It still smelled, so the next day we took it back to the laundry room and left it there. The TV looked like it was there from the 90s. The carpet in the room looked questionable. Once there were guests next door, you could hear very loud TV. Overall, I would say that the room was overpriced for its condition. We pay about $100 per night and we found it worth of about $65-70. No more.

Plussat: Great location, right on the water, clean, and a good value.

Miinukset: Nothing.

Plussat: Exceeded our expectations. Was clean and beautiful. Highly recommend.

Miinukset: The furniture was well worn.

Plussat: It was clean

Miinukset: Lots of dead knats and mosquitos on the ceiling. Bed headboard could use replacing. it is too noisy.

Plussat: Cozy. Right on the water. Quiet. Friendly staff.

Miinukset: Place is older. Could use some love. Overgrown or dead shrubs around porch. Old wallpaper in bath peeling.

Plussat: The room was nice and the view and location was super. A great value for the money and staff was very accomodating.

Miinukset: Was able to see some of the cottages also and likes #4, but would highly suggest removing the carpet and going with a pet friendly flooring.

Plussat: Location

Miinukset: Place was a dump, marketing really sold what it wasn't! Room was in need of a lot of repair, broken chairs, loose sink, damaged light switches. Common amenities were missing like no ice. Staff had no clue what was going on. Have boat slips but fail to tell you no launch. Place was extremely disappointing!

Plussat: We loved being able to sit at a little bistro table on the porch outside the room and watch the boats and ducks and drink our anniversary wine! The grounds were clean and there was a picnic table and grill to use if we wanted. In addition a fire pit to enjoy. The room had a nice refrigerator and there was a coffee maker, toaster and microwave as well. In the cabinet there were dishes and utensils to use. The bathroom and shower were good size for a small room. Good size closet also. We liked that there were 2 garbage receptacles. One for garbage and one for recyclables. Most of the time when we stay somewhere, we have to bring our recyclables with us.

Miinukset: We didn't like that the minute we walked in the room,it smelled extremely musty. My husband has breathing issues and so we needed to see if we could get it aired out. We had no screen door and 2 windows but only one screen. We had to run air conditioning constantly and leave door open when there except for sleeping. The bed seemed smaller than a queen, more like a full which was uncomfortable.

Plussat: Super value with an excellent view.

Plussat: Charming, waterfront, well equipped room, lovely friendly staff.

Miinukset: Booked at the last minute, the room had full beds...that wasn't clear. We made do. Loved this, our second stay.

Plussat: Good breakfast.

Miinukset: Toilet plugged twice. Shower drained slow. Staff didn’t fix this.

Plussat: AmericInn was very clean, and the staff was extremely polite and helpful. The continental breakfast was well stocked and had a nice variety. Rooms were clean, family and I enjoyed our stay. We will definitely be back at this location.

Miinukset: Nothing

Plussat: Traveled with my sister for a girls weekend in Door County. Location was perfect, staff was friendly, breakfast was exactly what we needed each day to get started, food area was always clean. We did not use the pool but many guests did and there was no noise from that in our room. Room clean and roomy for two ladies traveling together. Would stay here again. Bathroom was always very clean and shower was great!

Miinukset: One day the room had been cleaned but towels were left on the floor and one bed was haphazardly made.

Plussat: The room was big enough for all three of us. Clean and comfortable. Convenient to have breakfast on the way out the door

Miinukset: Bathroom was a bit on the small side. Black mold on the ceiling in the swim area

Plussat: The ambiance of lobby and several reading locations were my favorite. The pool was very nice for our grandchildren. And the breakfast was decent. Also like having sink in room separate from shower/toilet room.

Miinukset: No.

Plussat: Not enamored by it.

Miinukset: More fruit, better coffee.

Plussat: The room was big and clean. The bed was comfortable. Breakfast had lots of options. Staff was very friendly.

Miinukset: Nothing. Everything was great.

Plussat: The room was nice and very clean. But that is all i liked about the hotel.

Miinukset: The staff was rude and they did nothing about the screaming screaming and drunk people in the lobby at 2am.

Plussat: Pool and hot tub seemed dirty, not sure if it was just the color of the water. But didn’t seem clean

Plussat: The breakfast was good and fresh the place was clean and quiet

Miinukset: nothing

Plussat: Friendly staff, clean hotel, free daily paper.

Miinukset: Nothing, but it was a bit expensive.

Plussat: Great breakfast. Parking available for boat and tow vehicle.

Miinukset: Very poor lawn mowing job. Long cut grass everywhere in parking lot got into vehicle and dragged into room as well.

Plussat: Location, staff was nice

Miinukset: Someone was smoking drugs across the hall from us air conditioning wasnt working properly. Prices were jacked up because of a event in the area

Plussat: Nice pool area and hot tub. Used breakfast area for games at night. Staff all very nice, tolerant of my noisy gkids

Miinukset: Price but what can you do? The room smelled heavily of cleaning products when we arrived but it did clear

Plussat: Very convenient room to parking & breakfast

Miinukset: Carpet in hall & breakfast area worn out!

Plussat: The layout of our room was extra nice, especially for having two older kids it was nice to have a pull out couch so the kids did not have to share a bed.

Miinukset: Breakfast was just ok. It had all of the main items, but some items could have been a bit more upscale (I.e.-cooked oatmeal vs instant, scrambled eggs). Other than that everything really was perfect.

Plussat: Staff is super dedicated!

Miinukset: Nothing

Plussat: clean and pleasant

Miinukset: N/A

Plussat: Great room. Very clean, nice and quiet, lots of room to move around in. Good breakfast.

Miinukset: The only thing I didn't like was our room didn't have any Kleenex.

Plussat: A good value in an expensive county.

Miinukset: Refrigerator was a bit too loud--we had to unplug it for sleeping.

Plussat: Very nice accommodations. The room was quite large and very clean. I will definitely stay here again on my next trip to Door County.

Plussat: The check-in and check out were seamless, and most importantly - breakfast was really nice, with fruits, waffles and quite good omelette. Room is spacious, and there is a plenty of parking space as well. This was the only option available for the weekend we've spent in Door County, but I don't regret booking it, nice place.

Miinukset: I really felt a lack of lighting in the room, it was too dark even with all the lights on.

Plussat: The room was very large which was great.

Miinukset: The fact that the dining area employee was more interested in 'fronting' the food than letting people get thru the line to fill their plates. Also the tables were never wiped and were very sticky and dirty.

Plussat: Slept well; good pillows and mattress Close to main road to upper door county Morning breakfast good; appreciated 24/7 coffee with foldgers machine. Honored request for end room Staff were very friendly; great customer service.

Miinukset: There was a smell to the room; also had a damp feeling. Some rooms were hard floor, ours was carpeted. Black spots in bathroom near ceiling, otherwise clean. Dark room when shades shut and all lamps on.

Plussat: Very cute and clean.

Miinukset: The musty smell. we had to go to Walgreens and get febreeze and air fresheners.

Plussat: Being upgraded to a suite

Miinukset: Nothing that stood out.

Plussat: The staff was friendly and it was a great value for the area.

Plussat: The bed was ok.

Miinukset: The ash tray right outside my room.I thought it was a no-smoking room.

Plussat: It was quiet. The bathroom was clean.

Miinukset: We had a problem with the odor in our room. It wreaked of stale smoke. The smell permeated the drapes and bed linens. Some might call it partly from the cleaning solution but it has to be smoke because it has imbedded the textiles ie: sheets, pillows, curtains, bedspread and towels. The pillows were very flat.

Plussat: Comfortable and convenient.

Miinukset: Bed was to soft for me wife liked.

Plussat: Great location. Close enough to all of the places we wanted to visit but at a better price. Super cute and cozy.

Plussat: The location was great it’s a really cute place. The food around town was excellent and the shops were awesome. We were close to all the state parks and attractions.

Miinukset: The furniture was an issue, the bed was uncomfortable and hard to sleep on. The chair was broken so you sunk right into it.

Plussat: Cleanliness

Miinukset: too many "extendo stayers" as in non English speaking worker that LIVE there ..... we were put in a room with workers on both sides of us!

Plussat: The overall feel of the hotel. Totally classic and recently renovated bathrooms. There were utensils (plates bowls silverware and cups!) along with dish soap to wash everything! A toaster a hotplate and fridge and microwave!! This place was very considerate and accommodating.

Miinukset: Nothing! Everything was wonderful.

Plussat: Everyone that worked there was very nice and accommodating.

Miinukset: The floors could have been cleaner. I had to keep socks on all times. I think the carpets need cleaning. Should of had a little table and chairs instead of a desk. At least in the deluxe kitchenette rooms.

Plussat: Motel 57 was absolutely adorable! It was comfy and clean and well decorated! The staff were friendly they allowed us to have our dog with us and they even provided the room with everything you'd need in a kitchen! The room had a/c and a tv with cable which was nice for our tired and crabby toddler. Although the room was smaller, it was pretty spacious and it fit our pack'n'play with room to spare. Everything you need to rest between exploring Door County! Highly recommend! We will definitely be returning!

Miinukset: The shower curtain had some dirt on the bottom, but thats my only complaint.

Plussat: Great location! Very clean! Friendly staff, large rooms

Miinukset: Showers were a little dated

Plussat: Interesting history, nice patio/balcony areas, good breakfast.

Miinukset: Ongoing renovations in progress; our room had an unpleasant odor of unknown origin

Plussat: Pillows, bed, flooring, staff, and location were all great. Shower was also awesome. Very clean.

Plussat: The breakfast was better than expected. Plenty of choices, fresh and tast The location was picture perfect. The room was much better than the ad pictures.

Miinukset: The main restauant ran out of the prime rib special and no exception was made for a substitute. There were flies all over the salad bar. Appetizers tasted like they came out of a box and deep fried.

Plussat: The grounds by the pool area is very nice, relaxing. It was nice having a bar & restaurant on site. The Marina close by-scenic. The staff, especially, Duane & Danielle who went out of their way to accommodate us. You guys rock!

Miinukset: The balcony. It is semi-private with a partial wood wall. We were on the 2nd floor. You can walk from one end to the other seeing anyone sitting outside. The breakfast. While it wasn't the worst, I've seen better. They did have a young lady making omelets, but if I could suggest having more than 1 person making them, it would go much smoother-quite a line. I felt rather bad for the young lady. The food we ordered was ok, but not something we'd order again. We got a discounted rate for Labor Day weekend which we couldn't complain about, however, we wouldn't pay the full rate for the room.

Plussat: Beautiful setting and nice location.

Miinukset: The driveway In was not really a rode. Pot holes and not well paved. In addition, we left a note (in the morning) for housekeeping to clean our room, when we returned at 4:30 PM, the room was not cleaned.

Plussat: Good coffee, both at breakfast and in room

Miinukset: Selection kind of sparse, but ok. Missed out on made to order omelette station (guessing low guest rate this day of the week)

Plussat: The breakfast was great, but a long wait. We left and came back hoping for a shorter line. It was not to be.

Miinukset: Road into property and within the parking lots full of pot holes. Mold around bathtub faucet. Nails pushed up on decking, so a tripping and puncture hazard if barefoot.

Plussat: Being able to sit outside on the balcony in the evening and the omelette bar was great for breakfast

Plussat: Very clean & close to the downtown area with attentive staff.

Miinukset: Enjoyed the breakfast, but the coffee was terrible.

Plussat: The room was larger than anticipated, loved , the history about the lodge, will definitely stay again when in Door County, Drinks at Bar, were Great, Food not so much. Ordered the munchie Basket, menu had changed & not updated or informed about, deducued porion from the bill, but still disappointed, salad bar was weak and salad looked wilted. Besides that, we will DEFINITELY be back, but just drinks at Bar :)) Beds are a little more firm than we are used too, but I suppose better than being to soft

Miinukset: Bar food

Plussat: Bed very hard and uncomfortable

Miinukset: Bedding

Plussat: Breakfast was very good! Inn keeper Ruth was friendly.

Miinukset: Nothing

Plussat: Beautiful rooms and antique furniture. Breakfast was delicious. Owners were so nice and accommodating.

Miinukset: Room was dusty. The shower head was very short and in the jaccuzi tub. Hard to take a shower. Need more or thicker pillows on the bed.

Plussat: The room was clean and neat. Other guests were quiet and we did not seem to hear noise from anyone else, which was nice.

Miinukset: Breakfast main dish was the same both days. I think Ruth could be more warm and welcoming with her guests and not make them feel they need to rush out the door for checkout.

Plussat: Fabulous building. Exactly what we were hoping for

Miinukset: Surprisingly the breakfast was a little disappointing. The room was small with no wardrobe, just hanging space

Plussat: Breakfast was delicious. Ruth is a superb hostess.

Plussat: Cleanliness

Miinukset: Outdated and lonely environment

Plussat: Breakfast was awesome. Great value for the area (especially 4th of July week).

Miinukset: One of the reasons we stay at BnBs is for the personality of the owner/host - we hoped for a little more engagement and positive energy from our host this time.

Plussat: Location is great for everything in Sturgeon Bay. Room was spacious and clean

Miinukset: Breakfast was so so. Probably OK if staying only 1 night. We stayed 3 night and breakfast was pretty much the same each day. Very rigid schedule. 9:00 breakfast only. Breakfast room was uncomfortably silent. Maybe a bit of background music? Little to no interaction from hostess.

Plussat: Lovely old home, food was excellent, proprietor friendly.

Miinukset: The weather was cold and cloudy but what ya gonna do?

Plussat: Very thing was exactly

Miinukset: The people were vary nice and the view on the beach was amazing

Plussat: The rooms were sort of outdated and could use some sprucing up. The breakfast was really good. The location by the water was really nice. The staff were all really nice and helpful. We had a death in the family and had to leave a day early and we were refunded the last days money. That was very appreciated. I would stay here again. Location was good for touring the Peninsula.

Miinukset: The rooms were outdated and need sprucing up a bit.

Plussat: We love it here. It's the only place we stay. The beach is fun to relax at and love the live music.

Miinukset: Beds are uncomfortable.

Plussat: The scenery the lake and the boat ride

Miinukset: The rooms Cleanliness Bed sheets Breakfast

Plussat: They said there was breakfast...didn't get up early enough to eat before we had to leave. Location, location, location! Right on the channel! Quiet sleeping! Great mojitos at the restaurant that was right there!

Miinukset: Not updated but who cares.

Plussat: Decent private beach for kids

Miinukset: Looked considerably better online then in person. Extremely out dated and way over priced for the facilities. Bed was uncomfortable, carpet was dirty, sheets looked very old, tv was tiny with poor clarity.

Plussat: I liked the view of the lake, the food at the restaurant, the friendly staff, and the location.

Miinukset: The pillows were thin and old.

Plussat: Beautiful view and great place for fishing and rest. Kayaking, fire camp, around beautiful forests.

Miinukset: Food was not good and little fare from the other restaurant and shops. Our room was not too clean ( dirty carpet with lot of sand) but for fishing camp was ok.

Plussat: Everything was here. Food for lunch and dinner, a nice indoor/outdoor bar and a beautiful location right on the water.

Miinukset: Nothing

Plussat: It was right on the water.

Miinukset: The grass in the courtyard was very long. This is the focal point of the rooms and where you sit. First impression was not good. Quite a bit of rotted trim around the courtyard.

Plussat: THE LOCATION WAS AWESOME, GOOD FOOD, NICE ROOMS, GOOD BANDS.

Miinukset: THE BEDS WERE A LITTLE HARD.

Plussat: It was close to where we were going. That's about all.

Miinukset: A lot! The front staff younger man was extremely rude. There was no elevator and we had a lot of stuff to walk up stairs. The shower handle just twirled and when worked, only did scalding water or cold, the tub filled up with water, it wouldn't drain...

Plussat: Location was perfect, close to most activities. Plenty of options for the continental breakfast.

Miinukset: Sheets and towels were old and thin, lucky us that we brought our own towels. Bedspread maybe on the same bed for a long time. Everything is room is dated with minimal cleaning being done, bring disinfectant spray. Warning sign if you steal towels-HA HA

Plussat: Nothing. I don't think I'll ever stay at a Super8 again.

Miinukset: The room smelled like smoke. No fan in the bathroom. Advice for a restaurant was poor. The eggs were way undercooked, the sausage cold, and the waffle maker only cooked half the batter.

Plussat: Looks like they are doing some remodeling

Miinukset: too limited of space for breakfast. several guests sat in the room all morning (1.5 hours) leaving several of us to not have a table

Plussat: It was close to our destination

Miinukset: Staff hard to get ahold of. Breakfast was absolutely terrible. At 8am, there was no milk, no fresh fruit, raisin bran that you could break your teeth on, 2 stale bagels, 4 white pieces of bread, 1 expired yoghurt. I did see a pitcher of waffle mix. Horrid

Plussat: Clean, nice room. Good breakfast, pool and hot tub. Able to park my motorcycle where I could see it out my window.

Miinukset: Lighting in the room could have been brighter.

Plussat: Location for traveling we where doing

Miinukset: Not best condition within the room. Pool was closed, outside did not have a great curb appeal.

Miinukset: Bed blanket had holes in it...no outlets to charge phones or other electrical devices

Plussat: Location was great. Check-in was easy and the front desk attendant was very helpful and kind. Huge pool and nice hot-tub. Family-friendly!

Plussat: Price and indoor pool

Miinukset: No

Plussat: Room was clean

Miinukset: Beds are very outdated and need replaced. Had a king suite and the bed had holes in it and squeaked everytime you moved. And no ice machine or vending on second floor. Jacuzzi tub was nice.