Edinburgh hotellit lähellä Surgeon's Hall

Plussat: Everything -architecture , management etc

Plussat: The whole hospitality.

Miinukset: N/a

Plussat: It was lovey

Plussat: The location of the hotel and the room were excellent. We didn't try the hotel's breakfast as we were keen to explore the city. There were so many place to eat in Edinburgh that it seemed best to try a variety of places. The hotel's Afternoon Tea was superb though!

Miinukset: I don't think anything could be improved upon. We found the staff friendly, helpful an attentive throughout our stay.

Plussat: Impeccable elegance.

Plussat: Extremely fine accommodations. Every staff member was friendly, helpful, and wanted to please each guest.

Plussat: Zoltan at reception was a star. The restaurant and bar team were efficient and friendly. Rooms were clean and well appointed. Looking forward to our next visit

Plussat: I told them I am severely asthmatic. When I walked into the room I immediately smelled musty old rug that was cleaned at least dozens of times and exhausted its useful life a long time ago. I went back to the front desk and told them needed a different room for medical reasons and willing to pay more. The front desk person and the day manager told me that they did not have availability without any serious they said no without any consideration and force me to sleep in this room where I ended up wheezing all night. They also lied to me that all the rooms were renovated at the same time and were the same. And it turns out that there were at least a few rooms available.

Miinukset: The front desk staff should care about the wellbeing of their customers. Poorly trained and inconsiderate.

Plussat: The Number One was a tremendous experience. The hotel and restaurant staff could not have been better during our stay. I would simply say keep it up!

Plussat: Beautiful historic hotel in the perfect location. The staff could not have done more to be helpful. The room was beautifully decorated and extremely comfortable. The bathroom was spectacular.

Miinukset: The light level in the room was so subdued that it was difficult to see inside your suitcase. Other than that no complaints at all.

Plussat: the staff were lovely

Miinukset: booked double executive room, but think we got a budget room double bed two different height mattresses. asked them to sort it, they didnt. bathroom poor room smaller than stated in description

Plussat: very very good had all we required

Miinukset: Evert up its standard

Plussat: Everything about this hotel is fantastic, and consistently so. The service in particular is always outstanding.

Plussat: The One restaurant has excellent and unusual food servewd by impecably trained servers.

Plussat: Hotel staff are very attentive and quality of the meals excellent.

Plussat: The restaurant "Number one": excellent staff, good food. The location of the hotel and the view on the old city.

Miinukset: Very noisy hotel, not enough privacy: train station beneath the hotel, doors being smashed all day, staff knocking on doors to check on the room too often. The room had not been refurbished in a very long time. The bed was not particularly confortable. Much too expensive for the service provided and quality of the rooms.

Plussat: Lovely room, thoughtfully decorated, wonderful service.

Plussat: Room service was exceptional, the wait staff were fantastic and very helpful

Miinukset: The shower took about 10 minutes to warm up

Plussat: The room was very well-appointed with great finishes and amenities.

Miinukset: Location wasn't as close to everything as we'd have liked, but it was walkable.

Plussat: Aamiainen oli hyvä, suomalaisena kaipasin enemmän käsittelemättömiä vihanneksia.

Miinukset: katso edellinen vastaus

Plussat: Very good quality for room price :)

Miinukset: nothing :)

Plussat: Good location and very friendly staff.

Miinukset: Nothing

Plussat: Location and room

Miinukset: Staff at check-in gave some inaccurate information.

Plussat: The location of the hotel, the staff and the rooms were excellent.

Plussat: excellent location, great staff and very nice breakfast and restaurant food.

Miinukset: n/a

Plussat: Staff cheerful and gracious. Close to major attractions. Breakfast buffet good for price.

Miinukset: Television signals were sporadic. Tub was not cleaned.

Plussat: I got an upgrade to a big room. The bathroom was huge and I liked the seating area

Miinukset: The large standing floor lamp didn't work. The right wall lamp next to the mirror in te tv area had a dirty smudge on it and the bathroom didn't have any shower gel. The only product to clean was the tiny hand soap at wash sink.

Plussat: The staff were exemplary. The food was not overpriced it was good value for money and of an excellent standard.

Miinukset: Nothing.

Plussat: Our room and the hotel itself was very clean. Check in was a breeze. I would definitely recommend it.

Miinukset: During our 3 night stay, I called each day twice to request a straightener and they never had one. It worked out fine, but it was offered on the card in the room. I was hoping there would be at least one day I could use it. Otherwise, great stay.

Plussat: room only option - safe facility - reception staff very helpful - location

Miinukset: no bath but shower was good

Plussat: Very nice and comfortable room.

Plussat: Nice modern hotel in a quiet side street, very close to the theatre we were attending that night. Pleasant reception staff both on arrival and when leaving.

Miinukset: Attention to detail with regards to cleanliness, bedside tables and desk were very sticky, everything else was fine.

Plussat: Staff were very helpfull. The location of the hotel to the conference just across the road was excellent.

Miinukset: The heating system in the bedroom was quiet noisy when it was on.

Plussat: Ideal location, good food and with private parking

Plussat: Hyvä sijainti, siisti ja rauhallinen.

Miinukset: Niukka aamiainen verattuna mannermaiseen tasoon.

Plussat: henkilökunta oli ystävällinen ja auttavainen, erityisen mukavaa oli,että huonepalvelun hinta ei ollut kohtuuton verrattuna esim. hotellin ravintolan hintoihin. Yksin matkustava ei välttämättä halua istua ravintolassa yksin syömässä.

Miinukset: vastaanototssa ohjattiin väärään osoitteeseen kysysessäni missä koulutustilat olivat. Tilat olivat lähellä ja osoite oli tiedossa. Silti ohjattiin väärin. Olisin olettanut vieressä olevan kolutustilan olevan tiedossa.

Miinukset: Kylpyhuoneen oven kahva kiristettävä. Suihkun roiskesuoja myös löysällä.

Plussat: Very nice modern rooms, good location & very good value.

Plussat: Everything!

Plussat: Helpful welcoming staff. Well located for the city centre.

Plussat: A good clean well run hotel with friendly and helpfull staff .

Plussat: Very good breakfast and a lot of space which was great with a one year old. The grand cafe is very nice looking

Miinukset: Our room was a little old

Plussat: The location was fantastic, the building really interesting too. Rooms well appointed but no idea how the TV system worked.

Miinukset: Not much, great place.

Plussat: The staff was amazing, friendly, answered all questions we had before we got there.

Miinukset: Nothing, again the staff at the Scotsman was awesome!

Plussat: We had a warm welcome and our room was ready although we came one hour earlier as planned. The location is simply perfect and we love the newly opened 'The Grand Cafe' for Snacks, Dinner & Drinks. Thank you. We will return soon for a longer visit.

Miinukset: -

Plussat: Every aspect exceeded our expectations.

Plussat: Reception and the concierge were most accommodating and the hotel surpassed my expectations.

Plussat: Aamiainen oli hyvä, valikoima oli riittävä ja palvelu oli hyvää

Miinukset: Asuimme junior sviitissä, huone oli jo hieman nuhruuntunut. Hauska yllätys oli, että huoneessa 804 oli sauna

Plussat: Beautiful hotel to exceptional standard, will defo be back.

Plussat: Just back from a lovely two days away, I would recommend this hotel to anybody and we will definitely be going back later on in year. Thank you very much Scotsman hotel for a wonderful break.

Plussat: Beautifully elegant style, fantastic location and a wonderful vibe

Miinukset: We found a great deal, but think usually it would be a lot more expensive.

Plussat: It offers the best view in city center, and it is very convenient

Miinukset: Parking is not easy, it takes roughly 10 min to walk to the nearest parking lot

Plussat: Amazing hotel in a great location. Don't miss the wonderful nearby Southern Cross Cafe!

Plussat: Using the Vermillion lounge in the evening for a quiet drink was very pleasant. The Scottish chap with very short hair who attends the door in reception is a great asset to the hotel. We came accross him on several occasions he was always helpful, pleasant, professional and friendly, give him a large pay rise!!!!

Miinukset: We had some difficulty getting drinks in the Vermillion lounge. I dialed the number on the card as suggested but no answer. The chap from Chile who is studying for a Master in economic development sorted us out in the end, another significant asset for you hotel I hope you look after him

Plussat: Friendly helpful staff, very comfortable room, excellent service

Plussat: the staff were extremly friendly

Plussat: The quality fo the room was excellent and the free upgrade was very much appreciated, as were all the little extra touches.

Miinukset: The breakfast.

Plussat: We were upgraded to the publisher suite which was spacious and atmospheric. This really helped to make toe stay memorable. The staff were friendly and obliging. Overall an excellent service.

Plussat: Mutkaton, joustava ja henkilökohtainen palvelu. Kaunis design hotellin yleisissä tiloissa. Yöllä rauhallista ja hiljaista

Miinukset: Studio-huoneen sänky liian kapea kahdelle eikä huone muutenkaan niin viihtyisä. Ei vastannut esitteen kuvia. Kokolattiamatot ei sovellu allergisille.

Plussat: Everything!!!! The staff were excellent throughout- ur room was very spacious with a brilliant view over Edinburgh. Restaurant and bar were fabulous and enjoyed having the luxury of the spa right on the doorstep. Fabulously central location.

Plussat: The helpful staff

Miinukset: Could benefit from air conditioning

Plussat: All of the staff where extremely helpful.

Plussat: So very central. Useful to be able to get to the Waverley Station via the lower back door which was just a case of crossing the road to the station. Would be useful to enable access for booking into the hotel. Staff were helpful and friendly with no exceptions.

Miinukset: There was no 'heart' to the hotel. No where to sit peacefully other than the Bistro which was open to other customers and did not have seats to lounge in.

Plussat: Staff welcoming and courteous. Good size rooms and facilities excellent

Plussat: Very clean room. Amazing staff so friendly and polite. Will be recommending and will definitely stay in a Raddison blu hotel wherever I travel. Great service 10/10 - would give 11/10 if I could!

Miinukset: N/A

Plussat: The view where it was in the city was perfect.

Miinukset: There wasn’t anything I didn’t like.

Plussat: Loistava sijainti!

Plussat: Erinomainen aamiainen

Miinukset: Aamiaishenkilökunta ei hymyillyt kertaakaan.

Plussat: The hotel is well situated, on High Street, near the railway station, close to the Edinburgh castle and Princes Street, so it’s easy to walk from there almost anywhere you want to visit. The breakfast was good, lots to choose from at the buffet. The beds were amazing, after walking all day it was easy to relax and just drift off into sleep.

Miinukset: We had an issue with the staff one night, my friends were having a gathering downstairs because some of them smoke, they were not disruptive or making a mess, but a person on the staff saw them drinking some whiskey, we were after all buying whiskey that day and they were trying some out, and this person took the bottle from them, without reason, and the explanation was ridiculous, like we don’t allow drinking here? I guess they don’t allow it if you don’t buy it at their bar or something, because the glasses and ice they were using were from the hotel bar, they asked for them. Anyway, later one they ask for our property back, the bottle, because it was ours, but I wouldn’t have let them take it on the first place, if you don’t want your passengers drinking on your premises ask them to move it to the room or leave the space, but don’t touch what’s not your property. Two nights later or so we actually went to the hotel bar, charge what we had to our room, left, were just getting settled when they called us because they couldn’t find our credit card on the system or something, we had to get back down and tried to sort it out, but the truth is we never understood what was wrong with the card they had entered when we checked in; they even asked if I wanted to put that charge on another credit card, which I said of course not, they had a credit card on their system and that was the card they should use for the charge. After not learning what went wrong, or what they actually wanted, we finally went to bed. This whole thing could have been resolved the next morning, but no, we had to try and resolve it right then and there.

Plussat: Location, early check in, fab breakfast, good drinks and dinner....

Miinukset: Can't think of anything

Plussat: Great location, superb interior design of the room. Very modern style

Miinukset: In-hotel gym was temporarely out of service bu the hotel offered a free entry at a partner gym

Plussat: Spacious suite living room, separate half guest bath, Decent breakfast with separate order menu, gym had free weights to 30kg, location is on royal mile down road from castle (but for Christmas markets and shopping, a princess street hotel would been better), overall friendly staff.

Miinukset: 1. For a royal mile suite, main bathroom was standard. Overly spacious living room really could’ve spared space for a more comfortable bathroom befitting suite. 2. Website advertised kids eat free. However, when we ordered meals for the kids via room service, we were told it’s not free. Extremely deceptive and off putting of brand. 3. I emailed the hotel 1 week in advance of 4-day stay and asked for milk, orange juice, and water in room stocked and included room mini fridge. Email from customer service acknowledged request and even confirmed we still wanted wine and beer - a nice catch! However, when we arrived, we were informed juice and milk not included. False service promise should’ve not been made. Room service food was Not worth price (pizza, burger, and kids chicken meal were only ok but far more expensive than eaterery options all around).

Plussat: Location in a heart of Royal Mile, hotel is much bigger one can imagine from outside, comfy and clean room

Miinukset: Room was not ready by check-in time, had to wait, and when you are in a city for a limited time- this makes you unhappy. Guy at the reception desk with kilt was neither professional nor useful. Breakfast was decent but a bit busy for such a small room in such a big hotel.

Plussat: Location was perfect

Plussat: The room

Miinukset: There was a refurb going on so had to put up with constant drilling was not relaxing

Plussat: Old world charm meets modern amenities- you can't go wrong with this hotel right on the royal mike in Edinburgh. Excellent staff, well maintained rooms, and full service. Health club has good assortment of machines and free weights.

Miinukset: It's bloody cloudy in Scotland- spent an entire week and didn't see the sun once.

Plussat: the proximity to the main Edinburgh attractions, parking availability, supply of extra pillows, big rooms.

Plussat: good facility. hospitallity of staffs. and location.

Miinukset: somehow internet is not working properly good in both case of WIFI nor Wired connection.

Plussat: Easy to drive to and park my car. Ideal city centre location. Exclusive hotel for a rugby supporter's weekend.

Plussat: Room was very comfortable. There was lots of choice for breakfast. The hotel location was very good for castle and other attractions. We were near lots of restaurants.

Plussat: The upgraded room was appreciated we will stay here again.

Miinukset: Did not have breakfast - thought that £16.50 was expensive

Plussat: Henkilökunta oli todella palvelualtista, aamiainen ja sijainti oli hyvä.

Miinukset: Petyin kylpyläosastoon todella. Valitsimme hotellin sillä perusteella ja todellisuus ei vastannut odotuksiamme. Uima-allas oli vain 10 m pitkä ja vettä ei ilmeisesti vaihdettu riittävän usein (klooria kyllä käytettiin, mutta vesi oli sameaa), pesutilat kylpyläosastolla olivat nuhjuiset. Saunaa ei voinut käyttää oikein, kaikki kuuma ilma meni kiukaan päällä olevasta räppänästä suoraan ulos. Pukeutumistilat olivat epäkäytännölliset. Tuoksun perusteella tiloissa on jonkinlaista kosteusongelmaa. En käyttäisi kyseisestä tilasta sanaa kylpyläosasto.

Plussat: Erinomainen sijainti. Hotellisssa erittäin ystävällinen henkilökunta.

Miinukset: Aamiainen hieman kallis.

Plussat: Todella viihtyisä hotelli ja loistava sijainti. Matkustimme perheen kanssa ja erityinen plussa todella isosta huoneesta rauhallisessa paikassa (käytävän viimeinen huone).

Miinukset: Ei.

Plussat: Aivan keskeinen sijainti. Punttisali oli kohtuullisen hyvä, saisi olla vielä hedelmiä tms.

Miinukset: Vieressä viiteen asti yöllä aukioleva pubi, josta kantautuu mölinää läpi yön. Jos ei muista laittaa "älä häiritse"-lappua oveen, alkaa siivoajien koputtelu jo klo 8 jälkeen.

Plussat: Erinomainen sijainti ja erinomainen ystävällinen, avulias palvelu.

Miinukset: Festivaalien aikana kuului jonkin verran yöllä äänet kadulta.

Plussat: Good car parking. Close to city center. Great breakfast. Frendley staff

Plussat: Location

Plussat: EI ollut kummallinen aamupala

Plussat: The view and location are superb.

Miinukset: It was all good.

Plussat: Staff were lovely.

Miinukset: Looking a bit tired. Desk in room had big scratch on it. Also, on a previous stay breakfast was on the top floor which was lovely. This time we were in the lower part of the ground floor restaurant. The continental breakfast choice was quite poor considering the price. The toast was merely warmed up bread and coffee wasn't particularly hot. My elderly parents in their 80s, who were also staying, were unable to shower as they couldn't get in or out of the very steep sided bath.

Plussat: Our castle view room was exceptional. Very clean. Bed was comfortable and housekeeping was exceptional. Front desk staff very friendly.

Plussat: Lovely comfortable hotel with great views close to everything

Plussat: Location, facilities, helpful staff

Miinukset: Noise outside on Saturday night

Plussat: The location was perfect

Plussat: Sijainti uskomattoman hieno, sisustus tyylikkään moderni, palvelu ammattitaitoista.

Miinukset: Aamiaisella tuli tunne, että on yläluokkaisessa palvelupisteessä, jossa koko ajan kysytään mitä haluaa sen sijaan että saa vain itse toimia. Huoneessa tuli absurdi olo, sillä kahden hengen huoneessa oli kaksi noin 150 sentin levyistä sänkyä - ilmeisesti ylipainoisille amerikkalaisille. Muuten majoituksessa ei ollut mitään vikaa.

Plussat: Conveniently located in the Grassmarket district of Edinburgh within a very easy walk of several excellent restaurants and pubs, this hotel has an excellent view of the Old Town and the castle, which is only a few minutes away by foot. The room was spacious, the bed was comfortable, and the bar staff provided ice for no extra charge.

Plussat: Erinomainen sijainti, hyvä aamupala, joskin kovin meluisa tila.

Miinukset: Hotellin tupakkapaikka aivan huoneemme ikkunan alla. Brittiläiseen tyyliin huonosti eristetyt ikkunan ja kaikki metelöinti kuului suoraan huoneeseemme. Huoneessa ei saftyboxia! Hotelli oli kaikin puolin ok, mutta autopaikan kanssa 2 hh yli 600 euroa kahdelta yöltä!!!!

Plussat: The view of Edinburgh castle was out of this world.

Plussat: It has a great location, with lovely views of the castle and lots of food and bars nearby.

Plussat: Room very nice. cleanliness of room excellent. Staff friendly and helpful.Close to shops and visitor attractions.

Plussat: The views of Edinburgh

Plussat: Ideal city location for theatre, dinining and shopping.

Plussat: Paras sijainti, varsinkin iltamenojan kannalta

Miinukset: ei varsinaisesti, ehkä kova sänky

Miinukset: the bathroom was really dark with only lights over the wash basin. a large water stain on the ceiling was not very attractive!

Plussat: At arrival we were met in the parking lot by a very friendly man tha helped us with our luggage. The staff at the receptiondesk was very nice. The room was exellent. In the bathroom we were delighted to see a rubber duckling on top of the towels across the bath! It's the little things that count!

Plussat: Rapid sorting out/ upgrade when the door lock to out room failed

Miinukset: The fact thaty the door lock failed

Plussat: Convenience of location

Miinukset: As I had a front room over a weekend, the noise from the pubs in Grassmarket was a bit much.

Plussat: view of castle from hieghts restaurant, location of hotel

Miinukset: No fridge in room no radio having to pay for breakfast having to pay for internet access lifts very poor (not updated since previous college use) no air conditioning control windows not double glazed - noise, draughts

Plussat: Lovely room, friendly staff, great location. Visited for a birthday, and the staff made sure it was extra special

Miinukset: Shower in bathroom leaked slightly

Plussat: Location. Friendly Staff. The new bar/restaurant area looks good however the only downside is the seating area near the bar soon filled up and even though there were empty tables on the lower floor level there seemed to be a reluctance to give these to guests who just wanted a drink.

Miinukset: The reception area is still going through refurbishment which meant long queues soon began to build up when guests began arriving in numbers which was an inconvenience to be honest. No doubt this will be resolved when the work is completed.

Plussat: We liked the welcome and all the staff who were friendly and helpful. The room and bed were extremely comfortable, great breakfast and the whole stay was a delight. The hotel is very well placed for getting round Edinburgh. We would highly recommend and would definitely use it again.

Miinukset: Everything

Plussat: Good central location spotlessly clean and finished to a very high standard, you feel special being there

Plussat: Location, cleanliness and the staff who welcomed at door. They have a great manner and seem genuinely want to please guests.

Miinukset: Reception staff need much more warmth, smile more and actually treat people as such. Rooms clean bu quite small for price - felt a little cramped at time.

Plussat: Everything and everyone! If you want to be treated like royalty, have a stay!

Miinukset: Not a thing, was just amazing

Plussat: A very centrally located hotel with a freindly and helpful staff. The room was of a fair size with all you would expect of a hotel of this standing.

Miinukset: Although the room was finely furnished the room lighting was poor.

Plussat: The staff are exceptional from front of house to the cleaners value for money you can’t beat it

Miinukset: Nothing difficult to fault second time we have stayed in 3 months just as good both times

Plussat: Erinomainen palvelu. Erittäin siisti

Miinukset: Pieni huone

Plussat: Great room facilities, best breakfast, all the staff are friendly and helpful

Miinukset: Nothing

Plussat: Location. Exceptional staff.

Miinukset: Spa facilities would be nice. More options on breakfast

Plussat: The whole hotel experience at the George Hotel was completely faultless. The staff were incredibly helpful and welcoming. The rooms were spotless, warm and very comfortable. The breakfasts were delicious. The flight was cancelled on our return and had to stay at the George Hotel an extra night, the staff welcomed us back with mulled wine! Excellent stay, thank you.

Plussat: The hotel kindly acknowledged our anniversary. All the staff were wonderful.

Plussat: Brilliant location for all the reasons anyone would visit Edinburgh - sites shops reatauramts

Plussat: enjoyed the comfort and eating at the restaurant

Plussat: The hotel was in central Edinburgh and close to all the attractions.the room was very spacious

Miinukset: Lack of parking as public parking very expensive.

Plussat: Siisti huone, hotelli hyvällä paikalla

Miinukset: Maksu veloitettiin viikko ennen majoittumista kortiltani. Vain aulassa wlan toimi, Kerroksissa ei ollenkaan.

Plussat: Moderni avara ja erittäin siisti hotelli keskellä kaupunkia.Huoneet kauniit, ihanat sängyt, mahtava ruokasali ja ystävällinen henkilökunta.Stylish in Scotland!

Plussat: Palvelu oli nopeaa, hotelli sijaitsee tsi hyvällä paikalla lähellä bussiasemaa ja lentokenttäbusseja

Miinukset: Odotin hotellihuoneiden olevan hienompia.. Asuin 6. kerroksessa ja käytävät olivat melko kolkot. Aamukahvi ei ollut oikein hyvää mutta muuten aamiainen oli monipuolinen ja runsas.

Plussat: Hyvällä paikalla oleva siisti ja hyvätasoinen hotelli. Hyvä aamiainen. Hotellin sijainti hyvien kulkuyhteyksien varrella ja lähialueilla runsaasti ostos- ja ruokailumahdollisuuksia. Kaunis vanha rakennus ja yleisarvosana hyvä.

Miinukset: Meidän huoneemme oli melkoisen pieni ja näköala ikkunoista pari seinää ja pala kattoa. Huoneen koko/näköala ei vastannut hintaa. Tyypillinen sokkeloisen vanhan rakennuksen ongelma.

Plussat: Sijainti erinomainen, huone tilava ja siisti.

Plussat: location, standard of accommodation

Miinukset: bedrooms were very warm even with no heating on. We were unable to open a window due to noise on street. This was a minor complaint.

Plussat: I booked a room at The George Hotel as a special birthday treat for my husband. I wanted somewhere right in the city and this was the perfect location, we even managed to find a parking space! The staff were really friendly and helpful. The room was lovely and the bed was possibly the most comfortable I have ever stayed in!