Edinburgh hotellia

Plussat: We are regular users of the Bonham. The staff Are friendly and very helpful. Free upgrade to a suit which was Very roomy and luxuriously appointed with great view across the roofs of the city to the Forth. The whole hotel has been Recently refurbished to a high standard. Central location but very quiet. On site car park is very convenient but a tad expensive at £15 per night. Highly recommended.

Miinukset: Nothing.

Plussat: Juniorisviitti oli tilava ja mukava. Ikkunasta näkyi kivasti kaupunkimaisema. Hotelli sijaitsi todella rauhallisella alueella ja hotellihuone oli hiljainen, mutta silti hotellilta ei ollut pitkä matka nähtävyyksiin. Aamupala oli hyvä ja henkilökunta mukava.

Miinukset: Paying for car parking

Plussat: Very nice, well appointed and situated

Miinukset: No issues with the property!

Miinukset: Food at the restaurant was a bit disapointing

Plussat: The excellent service provided by all the staff.The breakfast

Miinukset: WiFi kept disconnecting Some areas of dust on parts of the room furniture

Plussat: Amazing lobby and exterior hotel. The bar and dining area was exceptionally beautiful. The room view was extremely pretty and the room itself very comfortable overall and clean.

Miinukset: Surprisingly compared to one of the similar hotels nearby I paid quite a bit more for this night but feel I had a far superior experience down the road from the hotel. If I'd not had better I would have had a very nice experience here. However I had free parking at the alternative hotel but they were charging a very high nightly rate here for parking due to their lack of car park facilities which another hotel had. For me it was a deal breaker Although this hotel had impeccable lobby and bar, the other hotel had rooms double or more the size, we got breakfast in bed complimentary and way more chic and antique and I paid far less for this experience. So if I had not had the previous hotels experience in the same row of hotels I would have loved this place, but I did find significantly better for less down the road in my personal opinion.

Plussat: We stayed for a week as our honeymoon was cancelled at the very last minute. Staff were professional and very friendly. We had a free upgrade (totally unexpected) very happy with our beautiful room. Menu was absolutely excellent great variety for all. Lovely bar and the library was a lovely place to sit and read a book. The hotel is close to all the local attractions and shopping areas especially the famous Princes Street. Under the recent covid 19 situation, we must thank all staff at the Bonham for their excellent service . We will be definitely recommending The Bonham Hotel to our family and friends. Thinking of you all at this difficult time stay safe .

Miinukset: Absolutely nothing lovely location .

Plussat: A smart and comfortable hotel in a good location close to the city centre. The breakfast was first class.

Plussat: The room was a good size and with lovely views of the city and the sea in the distance.

Miinukset: The web site is over generous in its praise of design features. The bathroom was only average in all respects and the hospitality tray poor for a hotel in this price bracket.

Plussat: Friendly and efficient staff,very comfortable room and a first class breakfast

Miinukset: Even with my best nit picking hat on could iI find any fault with the Bonham,a treat to stay there

Plussat: Huge bedroom with a great view of the church at Stockbridge. The location was excellent and I also loved the main course we had in the restaurant on the Friday night - 2 courses £14 per person - Exceptional value for money.

Miinukset: Service could be improved. Restaurant is open to the public and hotel guests don't get priority. In the morning, I had to ask for a number of things during breakfast.

Plussat: The clean and stylish appearance of the decor and the pleasant staff and enjoyable breakfast room

Miinukset: Breakfast cold table should be chilled in my opinion, especially the meats, cheese , yogurt and fruit. Room TV menu was not too great.

Plussat: Palvelu erinomaista, henkilökunta ystävällista ja avulisasta. Huone oli hieno ja siisti. Aamupala erinomainen.

Miinukset: huoneessa suuret ikkunat, joista kylminä päivinä kävi veto sisälle huoneeseen. Jos verhot edessä, veto ei häirinnyt.

Plussat: Tosi hyvä hinta/laatusuhde. Sopivan matkan päässä kaupungin sykkeestä, mutta silti rauhallisella paikalla. Aamiaiset erinomaiset, myös palvelu. Voimme suositella!

Plussat: Staff friendly;room decor very nice; centrally situated in a quiet area

Miinukset: Too hot!! (Rooms & corridors) Extremely difficult to get in & out of bath

Plussat: Relaxing envirnoment in the city, staff were extremely helpful! Will stay again. Highly recommended!

Miinukset:

Plussat: We were looked after very well by the staff and the hotel was central for all amenities.

Miinukset:

Plussat: Quality environment and relaxing atmosphere

Miinukset:

Plussat: Helpful staff - nothing too much trouble.

Miinukset: Car park.

Plussat: Lovely room, friendly staff, great location. Visited for a birthday, and the staff made sure it was extra special

Miinukset: Shower in bathroom leaked slightly

Plussat: Location. Friendly Staff. The new bar/restaurant area looks good however the only downside is the seating area near the bar soon filled up and even though there were empty tables on the lower floor level there seemed to be a reluctance to give these to guests who just wanted a drink.

Miinukset: The reception area is still going through refurbishment which meant long queues soon began to build up when guests began arriving in numbers which was an inconvenience to be honest. No doubt this will be resolved when the work is completed.

Plussat: We liked the welcome and all the staff who were friendly and helpful. The room and bed were extremely comfortable, great breakfast and the whole stay was a delight. The hotel is very well placed for getting round Edinburgh. We would highly recommend and would definitely use it again.

Miinukset: Everything

Plussat: Good central location spotlessly clean and finished to a very high standard, you feel special being there

Plussat: Location, cleanliness and the staff who welcomed at door. They have a great manner and seem genuinely want to please guests.

Miinukset: Reception staff need much more warmth, smile more and actually treat people as such. Rooms clean bu quite small for price - felt a little cramped at time.

Plussat: Everything and everyone! If you want to be treated like royalty, have a stay!

Miinukset: Not a thing, was just amazing

Plussat: A very centrally located hotel with a freindly and helpful staff. The room was of a fair size with all you would expect of a hotel of this standing.

Miinukset: Although the room was finely furnished the room lighting was poor.

Plussat: The staff are exceptional from front of house to the cleaners value for money you can’t beat it

Miinukset: Nothing difficult to fault second time we have stayed in 3 months just as good both times

Plussat: Erinomainen palvelu. Erittäin siisti

Miinukset: Pieni huone

Plussat: Great room facilities, best breakfast, all the staff are friendly and helpful

Miinukset: Nothing

Plussat: Location. Exceptional staff.

Miinukset: Spa facilities would be nice. More options on breakfast

Plussat: The whole hotel experience at the George Hotel was completely faultless. The staff were incredibly helpful and welcoming. The rooms were spotless, warm and very comfortable. The breakfasts were delicious. The flight was cancelled on our return and had to stay at the George Hotel an extra night, the staff welcomed us back with mulled wine! Excellent stay, thank you.

Plussat: The hotel kindly acknowledged our anniversary. All the staff were wonderful.

Plussat: Brilliant location for all the reasons anyone would visit Edinburgh - sites shops reatauramts

Plussat: enjoyed the comfort and eating at the restaurant

Plussat: The hotel was in central Edinburgh and close to all the attractions.the room was very spacious

Miinukset: Lack of parking as public parking very expensive.

Plussat: Siisti huone, hotelli hyvällä paikalla

Miinukset: Maksu veloitettiin viikko ennen majoittumista kortiltani. Vain aulassa wlan toimi, Kerroksissa ei ollenkaan.

Plussat: Moderni avara ja erittäin siisti hotelli keskellä kaupunkia.Huoneet kauniit, ihanat sängyt, mahtava ruokasali ja ystävällinen henkilökunta.Stylish in Scotland!

Plussat: Palvelu oli nopeaa, hotelli sijaitsee tsi hyvällä paikalla lähellä bussiasemaa ja lentokenttäbusseja

Miinukset: Odotin hotellihuoneiden olevan hienompia.. Asuin 6. kerroksessa ja käytävät olivat melko kolkot. Aamukahvi ei ollut oikein hyvää mutta muuten aamiainen oli monipuolinen ja runsas.

Plussat: Hyvällä paikalla oleva siisti ja hyvätasoinen hotelli. Hyvä aamiainen. Hotellin sijainti hyvien kulkuyhteyksien varrella ja lähialueilla runsaasti ostos- ja ruokailumahdollisuuksia. Kaunis vanha rakennus ja yleisarvosana hyvä.

Miinukset: Meidän huoneemme oli melkoisen pieni ja näköala ikkunoista pari seinää ja pala kattoa. Huoneen koko/näköala ei vastannut hintaa. Tyypillinen sokkeloisen vanhan rakennuksen ongelma.

Plussat: Sijainti erinomainen, huone tilava ja siisti.

Plussat: location, standard of accommodation

Miinukset: bedrooms were very warm even with no heating on. We were unable to open a window due to noise on street. This was a minor complaint.

Plussat: I booked a room at The George Hotel as a special birthday treat for my husband. I wanted somewhere right in the city and this was the perfect location, we even managed to find a parking space! The staff were really friendly and helpful. The room was lovely and the bed was possibly the most comfortable I have ever stayed in!

Miinukset:

Plussat: nice staff, so professional, 100 % recommendation

Miinukset: all was ok

Plussat: the location was great.

Miinukset: We got a room with no view at all.

Plussat: Everything

Miinukset: Nothing

Plussat: Staff very helpful large rooms which we found to be cold The fan air heating battles hard to keep the room warm and it very noisy. I would not choose to stay here again in the winter much better I would think in the summer

Miinukset: Cold corridor cold room and stone floors in the bathroom with no underfloor heating not great in the British Winter

Plussat: The Waldorf Astoria Caledonian hotel was nicely appointed. The staff was amazing. We ate at the Hotel breakfast. It had a wide variety of foods to choose from

Miinukset: My understanding Parking was extremely limited and we were charged a parking fee that required valet to park.

Plussat: Stunning in and out. Beautiful room, every amenitie was provided to us.

Miinukset: Breakfast was 25£.

Plussat: Staff

Miinukset: Beds

Plussat: Wonderful Location, wonderful old historical building, clean, well-maintained room, including bathroom.

Miinukset: Room was on the small side and view was inside courtyard - but no complaints given that it was a mystery purchase and the price was extremely reasonable.

Plussat: To be Honest this hotel falls far short of the quality I expect of a Waldorf Astoria Hotel. In fact I would suggest the senior management take a look at everything associated. The rooms are absolutely not worth the money not even if the rate was halved! the room service was abysmal and the food was to put it mildly not even on par with a greasy spoon. Couldn't even keep it hot from kitchen to my room 3 time!!!!! and sending me two electric heaters which in a huge room does about as much use as a chocolate teapot. AVOID and stay in a budget hotel as it will be better quality.

Miinukset: Everything about the stay was abysmal and in no way indicative of the rest of the waldorf brand as we stay in many all over the world. If I was the area manager or indeed a senior exec I would be ashamed to have it in the portfolio in the state it is in. Staff were ok, not as nice and approachable as others in the chain but pleasant. Doorman was the only plus. AVOID and stay elsewhere.

Miinukset: Fantastic 2 night stay im heart of Edinburgh. Lovely hotel and hospilality

Plussat: It was great ! The people was helpful !

Plussat: Location

Miinukset: It was old. The plumbing was defective. Vastly long corridors - creepy. Building needs demolishing and redevelopment

Plussat: The friendly and welcoming attitude of the staff, in particular the concierge. The have maintained the standard of the hotel since changing to a Hilton. It was well located for walking to Murrayfield for rugby.

Plussat: Service and attention to detail

Miinukset: Nothing to report

Plussat: excellent staff shame about the hotel.

Miinukset: qeues for brakefast,electrcity cutting out in the room due to faulty wiring. not a five star as far as i could see gets the rating on facilitys rather than class,

Plussat: nothing

Miinukset: It is a very old Hotel .It needs to be renovated urgently .The toilet flush is broken , noisy AC , non hot water avaliablility ( it was for a limited time but not expected from a five star Hotel ) . The staff talk without looking at your face with an unfriendly manner . The pool is again too old and need to be renewed so that the price paid to the Hotel is too much in comparison what you get .

Plussat: Good reception we arrived early room ready and all very efficient similarly check out very efficient

Miinukset: Breakfast, we were put in a cold room, toast took an age to produce , one poor machine and when we left the queue was 25 yards long to get in for breakfast

Plussat: Absolutely everything. I had always wanted to stay at the hotel and t lived up to all of my expectations

Miinukset: The only thing I would change would have been to have a bigger bed in our room. Kingsize just wasn't big enough!!

Plussat: Delightful! We hope to return to Edinburgh one day, and when we do, we will stay at the Caledonian.

Miinukset: Couldja make it stop raining?

Plussat: Everything was great except bed was very uncomfortable

Miinukset:

Plussat: The room was quiet and had a lovely view of Edinburgh. The staff were very helpful and the standard of cleanliness excellent. The leisure facilities were of a high standard also.

Miinukset: The price of breakfast seemed high even for the standard of hotel.

Plussat:

Miinukset: It was in reform so the outdoor appearance was not nice. I would have liked that in the website they had mentioned it.

Plussat: Price was good

Miinukset: Carpets, walls, lifts etc need cleaning and or renovations

Plussat: Everything

Miinukset: Nothing

Plussat: Kohtuullisen iso huone, siisti , mutta hieman jo kulunut. Ääni tulee hyvin käytävältä huoneisiin. Aamupala oli hyvä, mutta tuotteet loppuivat nopeasti koska hotelliin varsin iso.

Miinukset: Wc/kylpyhuone oli kulunut ja ovi heilui uhkaavasti.

Plussat: Huoneen koko ja sisustus hyvä.

Miinukset: Huone viileä. Termostaatilla ei saanu lisää lämpöä. Muutamia vikoja kylpyhyoneessa kuten pven kahvasta puuttui ruuvi, pyyheteline roikkui puoliksi irti.

Plussat: Everything spot on

Miinukset: Brill hotel very helpful staff couldn't do enough for you and bang on location great couldn't fault it

Plussat: Nothing at all

Miinukset: Everything is so bad the worst room service ever someday you won’t find a toilet paper The room was dirty when we arrived the door locks was broken, no view at all we can only se the garbage cans and car barking

Plussat: Location great. Staff usually very friendly and helpful.

Miinukset: Bedroom small, same size as bathroom nearly. No mini bar in room. Hairs on bath and bed (was also covered in fluff). Odd decor. Wanted £15 each for breakfast each day (or £12 if booked in advance on check in). Went elsewhere every day instead.

Plussat: Erinomainen hotelli,kauniit tyylikkäät huoneet ja henkilökunta oli ystävällinen ja avulias. Tulen käyttämään uudelleen ks hotellia ja suosittelen myös eteenpäin.

Miinukset: -

Plussat: Friendly personal, clear and cozy room, all furniture in good condition, nice location not so far from tram station! Highly recommend!

Plussat: The room was so lovely and welcoming, such a lovely treat to come back to a lovely bath after a long day of walking and exploring Edinburgh. A couple minutes walk to the tram stop to get into the centre. Staff were super friendly and welcoming.

Miinukset: N/A

Plussat: Sijainti oli hyvä: Haymarketin asemat vieressä, keskustaan kävelymatka. Aamupala melko monipuolinen. Hiljainen huone. Parivuode oli tukeva.

Miinukset: Aamupalalla suppea gluteenittomien tuotteiden valikoima: vain paahtoleipä ja yhdet murot. Laktoosittomia tuotteita ei ollut. Huoneessa ollut lisäsänky oli huono: lakana ei pysynyt ollenkaan nahkaisella pinnalla, ja asia korjattiin vasta kolmen yön ja kahden pyynnön jälkeen. Petivaatteita ei vaihdettu kertaakaan viikon aikana, ja ne oli pedattu huolimattomasti. Siivous muutenkin huonoa: mm. mukeja, laseja ja lusikoita ei vaihdettu puhtaisiin, pyynnöstä siivooja kävi "pesemässä" ne - hän huuhtoi ne vessan lavuaarissa ilman pesuainetta. Huoneissa on kokolattiamatto, jonka pölyisyys aiheutti allergiaoireita. Kylpyhuoneessa liian vähän pyyhekoukkuja, ja ne sekä pyyheteline roikkuivat seinästä kallellaan, lähes putoamaisillaan.

Plussat: Sijainti oli suhteellisen hyvä.

Miinukset: Hotellia suositeltiin erityisesti turisteille sopivaksi sijainnin ym takia. Hotellista ei kuitenkaan voinut varat tai tilata mitään lippuja aika siellä ole myöskään minkäänlaista tietokonetta asiakkaille. Henkilökunta ei myöskään pystynyt selkeästi opastamaan miten lippuja esim. linnakierrokselle olisi saanut. Poikamme sänky saatiin vihdoin kolmen eri pyynnön jälkeen valmiiksi klo 21:30. Olimme alun perin saapuneet hotelliin klo 11:00 ap. Klo 16 meille kerrottiin ettei sänkyä oltu vieläkään sijattu, mutta huoneeseen pääsisi. Palatessamme jälleen kerran takaisin ( illalla), sänky oli edelleen laittamatta. Klo 21:30 tuli lopulta huoltomies tuomaan petivaatteet ja laittamaan sängyn kuntoon. Olin kolmesti kysynyt hotellilta suoraan , oliko sänky riittävän kokoinen miehenmittaiselle teinille. Hotellin tiedoissa, Bookig.com sivuilla sanotaan, että sänkyjä on erikokoisia. Hotellista vastattiin lopulta edellisenä iltana, ettei sänkyjen kokoon voi vaikuttaa ! Olimme lähteneet liikkeelle Suomesta aamulla klo 05:30 joten oli aikamoinen pettymys koko touhu !! Sängyt ja tyynyt olivat kivikovia. Kylpyhuoneessa ei ollut lainkaan minkäänlaista käsisuihkua tai bideetä. Ei siis ammeen yhteydessä eikä muuallakaan vessassa. Ihmettelemme kuinka naiset ylipäätään pystyivät pesemään itsensä kunnolla. Ammeen hana oli pieni(lyhyt) ja kattosuihkua ei pystynyt laskemaan tai säätämään mitenkään. Käsisuihkuja ei myöskään ollut yhdessäkään hotellin vessoissa. Laktoosittomia maitotuotteita löytyi ainoastaan barista soijamaitoa. Puurokin oli tehty tavalliseen maitoon. Lisäksi olisi mielestämme kohtuullista infota sivuistalla adapterin tarpeellisuudesta. Hotellin yhteydessä ei ole mitään paikkaa/ mahdollisuutta istua ulkona/ terassilla. Ruokailutila on pieni eikä siinä ollut juurikaan mitään viihtyisää erillistä paikkaa jossa olisi voinut istahtaa.

Plussat: Friendly staff. Good location

Plussat: All the staff were very friendly,welcoming and helpful right from reception through to being served for breakfast and the lady that cleaned our room

Plussat: Everything, food was lovely, breakfast excellent value, rooms clean and comfortable and friendly staff.

Plussat: Location - walking distance to railway station and city centre shops, restaurants and Usher Hall. Good price point

Miinukset: Nothing - suited us

Plussat: The Hotel is only 10 minutes walk from Princes Street and very close to the Airlink from the Airport. The room was clean, spacious and well equipped. The Buffet breakfast was very good and the staff coped very well with the volume of customers, due to the Rugby international at Murrayfield.

Miinukset: The lifts were a bit slow - everything else was good.

Plussat: Ystävällinen henkilökunta, puhui englantia selkeästi. Yleisvaikutelmaltaan siisti hotelli.

Miinukset: Huoneissa ja käytävässä oli hieman tunkkainen haju, kun ulkoa meni hotellihuoneeseen sen huomasi heti. Tuli tunne, että kokolattiamatoissa muhi jotain. Hotelli oli muuten siisti.

Plussat: Hintaansa ja sijaintiinsa nähde erinomainen valinta matkustaville esim. perheille. Rauhallinen ja siisti. Ilmastointi puuttuu, joten kesällä voi olla tukalaa.

Plussat: Kaupunkilomalla itsenäisesti liikkuuvalle sopiva hotelli pääkadun läheisyydessä kuitenkin jo rauhallisella alueella. Lentokentältä helppo tulla ja lähteä bussilla (myös yöllä). Monipuolinen aamiainen.

Miinukset: aamupalatila hivenen ahdas, hotelli oli tuolloin todella täynnä

Plussat: Siisti, hiljainen, sijainti todella hyvä kaupunkilomalaiselle, henkilökunta resepsuunissa ystävällisiä, samoin kerrossiivoja.

Miinukset: Huoneen ovien sulkeutumistekniikka aika kovaääninen, ovet paiskautuivat kiinni.

Plussat: Vaikka on kyse suuresta hotellista palvelu toimi moitteettomasti, erityisesti aamiainen sujui hyvin. Kerroshenkilökunta oli ystävällinen.

Miinukset: Vastaanottohenkilökunnan työpaineitten takia matkalaukkujen palauttaminen säilytyksestä tuotti vaikeuksia.

Plussat: The staff were generally sincere and helpful. The breakfast was good.

Miinukset: No free wifi service, a bit inconvenient for guests who want to connect with the office or to check travelling information.

Plussat: Close to the eicc

Miinukset: Room was quite warm even with a table fan